Alexandre.J's Black Muscs has sparked divided opinions in the fragrance community, with many drawing comparisons to Montale's more established rose-musk compositions. This unisex creation centers around a straightforward duo of rose and musk, garnering both appreciation and criticism for its simplistic approach. While some enthusiasts embrace its Arabian-inspired character and versatile wear profile, others point to its synthetic nature and limited development as significant drawbacks. The soapy rose heart, underscored by musk, fails to justify its premium pricing for many critics. Despite its shortcomings in longevity and complexity, Black Muscs remains a wearable option for those seeking a simpler take on the rose-musk theme.